Apple, Google and Meta Launch Last-Minute Fight Over Canada’s Spy Bill

Apple, Google and Meta are renewing their fight against Canada’s proposed surveillance legislation, warning that Bill C-22 still threatens privacy and security despite changes made by Ottawa.
According to Bloomberg, tech companies are pressuring the government to rewrite the legislation as it moves through the Senate. Representatives from Meta, Signal and Tailscale were scheduled to testify on November 16.
Apple maintains the bill could weaken security, while Meta’s Canadian policy chief Rachel Curran called weaker protections a “red line.” Signal has threatened to leave Canada, and Proton is reconsidering expansion plans.
Bill C-22 passed the House of Commons on June 18 but has not become law. It would give police and CSIS expanded powers to obtain subscriber information and allow certain providers to be required to retain metadata for up to six months.
Ottawa already amended the legislation following objections from Apple and Google, adding protections against requirements that create systemic security vulnerabilities. However, those changes have not satisfied critics.
In May, Apple warned that secrecy provisions could prevent it from alerting users. DuckDuckGo threatened to withdraw its VPN, while Signal said it would rather leave Canada than compromise encryption.
By September, 20 technology companies and industry groups were demanding further changes.
Canada’s Privacy Commissioner has also criticized the bill’s broad subscriber-information powers and called for stronger independent technical oversight.
How does Canada compare?
Similar laws exist elsewhere. The U.K. permits certain data retention for up to 12 months, while Mexico requires specified telecommunications records to be kept for 24 months. The U.S. requires covered carriers to support lawful interception, but includes limits on decryption obligations.
The EU generally prohibits indiscriminate retention of traffic and location data for ordinary crime prevention.
Ottawa insists Bill C-22 “does not authorize indiscriminate surveillance,” but critics argue the remaining powers still need stronger safeguards.
Should Canada strengthen its surveillance powers if major technology companies say doing so could weaken user privacy?
Want to see more of our stories on Google?
P.S. Want to keep this site truly independent? Support us by buying us a beer, treating us to a coffee, or shopping through Amazon here. Links in this post are affiliate links, so we earn a tiny commission at no charge to you. Thanks for supporting independent Canadian media!