Meta Warns WhatsApp Could Leave Canada Over Spy Bill

Meta says it would consider withdrawing encrypted services such as WhatsApp from Canada if Bill C-22, Ottawa’s lawful access bill, passes without further changes. The company told senators Monday evening that the current proposal still threatens the security of private messages, despite amendments meant to protect encryption.
According to CBC News, Meta privacy and public policy director Robyn Greene told the Senate’s national security committee that complying with the bill while continuing to provide secure, end-to-end encrypted services would not be technically feasible.
Asked whether Meta could pull services from Canada, Canadian public policy director Rachel Curran said it would have to “review all of our options.” She argued that the changes protect the core of encryption but leave other essential layers exposed.
Meta has not announced a Canadian shutdown or a date for one. Its warning is conditional on the legislation going ahead without the changes it wants.
The bill passed the House of Commons in June and remains before the Senate. It would establish technical requirements so providers can supply information when police or CSIS have legal authority to obtain it. The Public Safety minister could also issue confidential orders requiring particular capabilities, subject to review and approval by the Intelligence Commissioner.
Ottawa says the bill does not require backdoors or give investigators direct access to providers’ systems. Its amendments say providers cannot be compelled to decrypt information unless they supplied the encryption and possess what is needed to decrypt it. The government also says providers can refuse obligations that would introduce systemic security vulnerabilities.
Another change caps mandatory metadata retention at six months rather than a year. Metadata describes an exchange, such as its timing or participants, rather than the message itself.
Signal has also warned it could leave Canada rather than compromise users’ security. Apple, meanwhile, told CBC News that the amended bill still risks undermining its privacy and security features.
Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne has welcomed improvements but wants further safeguards. In his November 2 Senate statement, he called for a narrower definition of subscriber information and tighter limits on who could be required to disclose it under the bill’s lower reasonable-suspicion threshold. He also recommended letting providers seek an independent expert assessment before complying with potentially harmful requirements.
Pulling WhatsApp out of Canada would be a huge decision, and it’s hard to see Meta going that far. Still, even raising the possibility puts the spy bill in the headlines and brings more attention to its potential consequences. It also leaves a bigger question: if Ottawa and Meta cannot agree on encryption protections, what would the company actually do?
Would losing access to WhatsApp change how you stay in touch with family and friends?
Want to see more of our stories on Google?
P.S. Want to keep this site truly independent? Support us by buying us a beer, treating us to a coffee, or shopping through Amazon here. Links in this post are affiliate links, so we earn a tiny commission at no charge to you. Thanks for supporting independent Canadian media!