Apple Allegedly Pushed Sports Organizations to Infringe a Video Patent

At the start of a federal trial yesterday, a lawyer for Israel based Emblaze Ltd. told the jury that Apple pushed organizations such as Major League Baseball to adopt its format for streaming live video, causing them to infringe a video patent, Bloomberg reports. The company is arguing that Apple infringed its U.S. patent that covers a process for delivering live-streaming video over wireless networks without interruption.


Martin Pavane, who made his opening statements to a jury of five women and four men in San Jose, California, is representing Emblaze’s case against seven video-streaming services, including’s “At Bat” and WatchESPN. “Apple’s HLS (HTTP live-streaming service) is nothing more than Emblaze’s patented solution under a different name,” he argued. 

“Apple began working on its HTTP live-streaming service, or HLS, “no earlier than 2007,” demanding that services such as “At Bat” use the format to drive sales of iPhones and iPads — and inducing infringement of Emblaze’s patent, Pavane said.

Apple lawyer Mark Fowler in reply, told jurors that the iPhone-maker’s success has made it a target of patent suits. Emblaze, by comparison, is a failure “trying to make up for that lack of success in the courtroom,” he said.”

Mr. Fowler also told jurors that he will prove that Emblaze’s patent is invalid and that none of the seven accused streaming services infringe it.