During the 2019 federal election campaign, Facebook removed a “false and inflammatory” story about Prime Minister Justin Trudeau after a request from the country’s top civil servant, while similar actions were not taken when it came to misinformation about Conservative leaders on WeChat in the subsequent 2021 election.
This contrast in approaches to handling misinformation was highlighted during a public inquiry on Friday into foreign election interference, reports the Globe and Mail.
The allegedly falsely story on Facebook claimed Trudeau had an affair with a student at a school he was teaching at in 2000, and was published by the Buffalo Chronicle. Concerned about its potential to “risk threatening the integrity of the election,” officials from the Privy Council Office, led by Allan Sutherland, sought its removal. Facebook complied, eliminating the story from the social network.
But during the 2021 federal election, misleading stories targeting Conservative leader Erin O’Toole and MP Kenny Chiu circulated on China’s WeChat. These included claims that O’Toole wanted to cut diplomatic ties and that the Conservative platform scared Chinese Canadians. Despite these issues being flagged to officials, no request was made to WeChat to remove the misleading content.
“It was written in Mandarin meant that the content would only reach the Chinese diaspora,” explained Sutherland to the inquiry.
“In addition, the Buffalo Chronicle article presented false and inflammatory information directly targeting the Prime Minister’s character, whereas the WeChat postings discussed substantive policy issues, albeit also in an inflammatory manner,” Sutherland explained.
The Trudeau story on Facebook was “highly inflammatory and was seen that it might go viral and become a national event,” Sutherland explained during the inquiry. “I was simply observing that in the case of WeChat, the ability to go viral on a national scale is different.”
“I do not want to leave you with the impression that it was treated with any less seriousness. I am only observing that they had different qualities,” said Sutherland.
The Globe and Mail revealed in May 2023 that Conservative MP Michael Chong was targeted by China in the 2021 election, while CSIS informed O’Toole and NDP MP Jenny Kwan they were also under the influence of similar actions by the CCP.
Want to see more of our stories on Google?
P.S. Want to keep this site truly independent? Support us by buying us a beer, treating us to a coffee, or shopping through Amazon here. Links in this post are affiliate links, so we earn a tiny commission at no charge to you. Thanks for supporting independent Canadian media!
The consequence of throwing everything under the rug is coming to fruition now.
Sadly we can’t call an election that I know of, but at least we get vote these clowns out soon. Counting the days.
Such an embarrassment currently.
Fruition? Someone got an email message with a new the word of the day.
It would have been a good idea to clarify that Facebook and WeChat are two different companies in two different countries, so their policies are likely different in handling such reports. The story as written makes it sound like FB is pro-Liberal, and that the Conservatives are treated unfairly (which they are, but not by Meta).
And by your reasoning, Trump is being treated unfairly too.
Ignored, not ignored. This happened in the past, not the present.
And who’s to say it can’t happen in the present? Such a shortsighted opinion. Blind loyalty to your preferred party isn’t an excuse.
What kind of crooked conspiracist are you? I was making a grammar correction on the incorrect use of tense in the headline on an article about something that HAPPENED not something that they are reporting as happening. I never said it can’t be happening right now nor did I express any opinion whatsoever that could even remotely suggest what I think about the subject.
Me: this article is about something that happened in the past but you made a spelling error in the headline
You: your opinion is shortsighted even though you didn’t express any opinion at all and my made up fantasy tells me you’re a blind political tool even though I have no idea what party you support!
It’s alright. Gen Y and Z and even some dinosaurs get most of their facts from TikTok , YouTube, and Truth Social these days.