Carney Says Less Telecom Choice Could Lead to More Competition

Four smartphones displaying Rogers, Telus, Bell and Freedom Mobile logos

Prime Minister Mark Carney says fewer telecom companies can sometimes mean more competition. With Quebecor trying to buy Telus, that argument puts Ottawa’s push for a fourth national wireless player back in the spotlight.

In a November 18 clip shared by Scott Robertson, Carney pointed to telecom and financial services as areas where Ottawa wants competition to improve affordability.

“We have a competition lens, a pro-competition lens, because that’s what’s going to drive affordability for Canadians,” he said.

Carney then argued that the outcome depends on how a market is structured.

“Depending on the market structure, the form of oligopoly can lead to more competition with fewer players under certain circumstances.”

He said Ottawa needs informed decisions, with lower prices and better service guiding its choices.

“But when push comes to shove on any decision, if we can have more competition. Lower prices, better service for Canadians. That’s where we’re going to land.”

Ottawa Previously Made the Case for Four

That is a different emphasis from the Trudeau government’s defence of a fourth national carrier. On March 31, 2023, then-industry minister François-Philippe Champagne said the evidence favoured a strong fourth competitor.

“The evidence is clear: Having a strong fourth competitor does lead to lower prices,” Champagne said.

Champagne had denied the transfer of Freedom Mobile’s spectrum licences to Rogers. He instead approved their transfer to Videotron under conditions that included options at least 20% cheaper than the major carriers’ offerings and a ten-year restriction on transferring the licences.

The goal was to strengthen an independent rival to Rogers, Bell and Telus. Quebecor’s roughly $31 billion CAD proposal would now combine Telus with the owner of Freedom Mobile, Videotron and Fizz, leaving three large national wireless groups.

Carney’s comments do not announce a policy reversal or endorse that takeover. Ottawa has said it will not predetermine the regulatory reviews, and the proposal remains non-binding.

Would Bigger Mean Better for Customers?

An oligopoly is a market dominated by a few companies, which can still compete fiercely. A merger could lower costs or combine networks to create a stronger challenger. Canada’s own competition-policy discussion paper recognizes those potential benefits.

But fewer independent carriers means fewer independent choices. Keeping several brand names does not change that if the same company controls them. Carney’s framing risks dressing up a loss of choice as a win for competition before anyone has shown that customers would benefit.

His qualification matters: a merger can sometimes make a business a tougher competitor. But that is not the same as giving Canadians more choice, and lower operating costs do not guarantee lower bills. Removing a rival that pushes others to offer better deals could do the opposite.

The Competition Bureau’s 2020 analysis found prices were generally 35% to 40% lower where wireless disruptors had more than 5.5% market share. A European regulators’ study also found some evidence of higher new-customer prices after four-to-three mobile mergers in Austria, Ireland and Germany, although results varied.

Freedom Has Already Pushed Rivals to Respond

This is not just an economic debate. On Boxing Day 2023, Freedom increased its $34 CAD Canada-U.S. plan from 30GB to 50GB. Rogers’ Fido, Telus’ Koodo and Public Mobile, and Bell’s Virgin Plus followed with $34 CAD/50GB offers, but did not match the U.S. roaming. That is a concrete example of an independent rival pushing the Big Three’s lower-cost brands to offer more.

Freedom has also challenged what Canadians should pay for global roaming. Its March 2026 promotion offered 250GB for $40 CAD per month after discounts, including a 50GB global roaming allowance across 120 destinations. Public Mobile offered 250GB for $50 CAD, but with roaming only in the U.S. and Mexico. These were temporary offers, not current prices, and the global coverage was not a like-for-like match.

Freedom does not explain every price change in the market. But its lower prices, bigger data buckets and included roaming have given customers a reason to switch and rivals a reason to respond. Losing that independent pressure would be a serious trade-off, not an obvious improvement.

Quebecor says greater scale would help it compete with satellite operators and fund networks. Canadians spent years being told a fourth national carrier was needed to challenge the Big Three. They deserve more than a theoretical explanation for why going back to three might now be good for them. Carney has not shown that this proposed deal would lower bills or improve competition. Until that case is made, presenting fewer players as a route to more competition deserves pushback, not a free pass.

Do you think combining Telus and Freedom Mobile would bring Canadians lower prices, or leave them with fewer reasons to switch? Let us know in the comments.

Want to see more of our stories on Google?

Add iPhone in Canada as a Preferred Source on Google

P.S. Want to keep this site truly independent? Support us by buying us a beer, treating us to a coffee, or shopping through Amazon here. Links in this post are affiliate links, so we earn a tiny commission at no charge to you. Thanks for supporting independent Canadian media!

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x