Consumer Groups Warn Carney’s Spy Bill Could Put Everyone’s Data at Risk
OpenMedia and 25 other organizations and experts are asking Prime Minister Mark Carney to step in before the Senate finishes reviewing Bill C-22, Canada’s lawful access bill.
They want Ottawa to drop the power to make companies keep records on all users and close what they see as a loophole that could let the government get around encrypted messaging.
The November 19 letter, signed by groups including Amnesty International and the Internet Society, asks Carney to have the government’s Senate representative back two changes:
- Remove the power to require companies to keep metadata on all users. That can include who contacted whom, when and where. The groups say police can already use targeted orders to preserve and obtain records relevant to an investigation.
- Explicitly bar regulations and ministerial orders from getting around end-to-end encryption, including by capturing messages on a device before encryption or after decryption. The groups also want court authorization for these obligations and for them to be public by default.
“The Prime Minister wants to govern a sovereign Canada economically integrated with Europe, and whose values celebrate protecting people most at risk. Yet his own legislation undermines this vision. Europe will not integrate with an economy where apps can be secretly forced to backdoor their services — that’s against their laws and values, and it should be against ours. And no democracy should force basic services to keep a ‘filing cabinet’ of sensitive data on millions of its citizens suspected of no crime, just in case police want it one day,” said Matt Hatfield, Executive Director, OpenMedia, in statement.
Why Apple, Google and Meta are still pushing back
Ottawa introduced C-22 in March after splitting the lawful-access measures out of its earlier border bill, C-2. In May, Apple privacy executive Erik Neuenschwander told MPs that building a backdoor would create an opening for hackers, not just police. He also warned Apple could be barred from telling Canadians what the government had ordered it to change. Google Canada’s Jeanette Patell said secret ministerial orders could force companies to build interception capabilities and that police already had tools to preserve data in specific investigations.
The House passed the bill on June 18 after Ottawa moved to address some of those objections. MPs cut the maximum retention period from a year to six months and limited compelled decryption to data the provider encrypted and already has the means to unlock. Ottawa says authorities still need legal authorization to obtain personal information. The new letter argues a provider could still be ordered to capture a message before it’s encrypted or after it’s readable on the recipient’s device.
At the November 16 Senate hearing, Meta’s Robyn Greene said the company couldn’t comply with the bill as written and still provide secure, end-to-end encrypted services. Meta’s Rachel Curran said the company would review its options, including whether to pull services such as WhatsApp from Canada. Signal’s Udbhav Tiwari went further: his company would leave rather than weaken security for Canadians.
Apple and Google are scheduled to return to Parliament on November 23, this time to appear before the Senate’s national security committee. Apple’s Neuenschwander and Google’s Patell are on the witness list alongside Google threat intelligence analyst John Hultquist and Windscribe founder Yegor Sak.
“There is no back door that only the good guys can walk through,” said Natalie Campbell of the Internet Society in OpenMedia’s announcement.
The signatories warn the bill could put at risk an EU privacy designation that allows European businesses to transfer certain personal data to Canada without extra safeguards.
Bill C-22 is still before the Senate’s national security committee, where senators can recommend changes.
Should Ottawa drop the power to make companies keep records on everyone and stick to orders tied to specific investigations?
Want to see more of our stories on Google?
P.S. Want to keep this site truly independent? Support us by buying us a beer, treating us to a coffee, or shopping through Amazon here. Links in this post are affiliate links, so we earn a tiny commission at no charge to you. Thanks for supporting independent Canadian media!
